Discover Yahoo! With Your Friends

Explore news, videos, and much more based on what your friends are reading and watching. Publish your own activity and retain full control.

To get started, first

YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    H&M accused of stealing ‘You Look Nice Today’ design

    A woman has accused high street retailer H&M of stealing a design from her hometown and using it as a part of their home collection.

    When Tori LaConsay took the time to paint a sweet message on a neighbourhood sign she had no idea a lookalike design would end up plastered over merchandise on the retailer’s website.

    In December 2008 Tori, from The East Village neighbourhood in Atlanta, Georgia painted ‘You Look Nice Today’ with a love heart on one side of a road sign so people could see it as they travelled past.

    Tori LaConsay's original design.


    Unexpectedly, Tori received messages from friends recently with links to the UK H&M website showing her design on doormats, pillowcases and towels with no accreditation.

    H&M Home launched in Sweden, Germany, Finland, Austria and the Netherlands in 2009, it was introduced to the UK 2010.

    Tori told regretsy.com that her painting was an act of appreciation for her town and the people that she lived in it with. She said: “It was a small gesture that I genuinely hoped would make my neighbours feel good.”

    A lookalike of Tori's design on the H&M site.

    [See also: Australian fashion chain issues jaw-dropping response to customer complaint]


    She emailed H&M with a complaint but they dismissed her claims with the following response:

    “We employ an independent team of over 100 designers. We can assure you that this design has not been influenced by your work and that no copyright has been infringed.”


    According to regretsy.com, H&M originally posted a message on their Facebook wall apologising for the intention it may have created and said copying is not tolerated in their business. They claim they were inspired by a variety of text messages and created something from that in a similar font. The post can be seen here.

    The design in question on guest towels.


    Her friend also sent in complaint to H&M’s customer service and received an unhelpful and abrupt response.

    Tori’s friends then took to the H&M Facebook page to express their thoughts about the alleged copies of ‘You Look Nice Today’ design appearing on the website but they say the comments were quickly removed after emerging on the H&M wall.

    Responding to the complaints, H&M posted a message to say that they were in contact with Tori and their post received hundreds of comments and ‘likes’ from users.

    H&M removed the items from their e-commerce website and posted a further statement on their Facebook page on the 25 January saying: “We are very sorry for our customer service team´s reply, it is very unfortunate and we apologize for it. We are in contact with Tori LaConsay and will continue the dialogue with her directly.”

    What do you think of this situation? Is this inspiration or is this a case of copy cat? Let us know below.

    Follow @YLifestyleUK on Twitter

    H&M admit to using computer-generated fashion models

    Shoppers complain about M&S handbag that 'smells of fish'

    Model mocks American Apparel plus size competition

     
    • Vic.  •  Aberdeen, Scotland  •  3 months ago
      How much did H & M pay their advertising company who obviously stole this idea.
    • Ann  •  London, England  •  3 months ago
      The idea is obviously copied. H & M are missing a trick though - sack the designer who copied it and pay Tori to design for them! The feel good of that would help sell their products too.
    • huppity  •  Reading, England  •  3 months ago
      let's face it, if I decided to put something similar outside my house (I have never shopped in HM so had no idea) am SURE I would be receiving a letter from HMs solicitors asking me to remove it!
      • callum 3 months ago
        No you REALLY wouldn't...
      • callum 3 months ago
        Don't believe me? Give it a try. I will personally pay any fine they try and get out of you AND give you the money as well.
      • lorri 3 months ago
        The council would tell you too take it down. you need permission for a sign
    • Binary star  •  Cambridge, England  •  3 months ago
      She must be gutted that she didn't take out a patent on her design, now there's not a lot she can do about it
      • Belial 2 months ago
        You don't need to patent artwork for it to be covered by copyright afaik.
    • jimbo  •  3 months ago
      guaranteed if it was the other way round, this pirate company would be suing her under copyright and wasting their money destroying a ordinary person..
    • Fencer 4 Him  •  Edinburgh, Scotland  •  3 months ago
      exactly the same!!! No differences, what a shame!
      • EDNA 3 months ago
        not exactly the same sorry. The heart is not in the same place and no full stop.
      • Kurt 3 months ago
        Also the 'T' in today's not in the same place. You can't copyright a phrase that millions of people use every day. I've just copyrighted 'Good Morning' so don't any of you lot be saying it without paying me Royalties. LOL!!
    • Tony  •  Renfrew, Scotland  •  3 months ago
      Hard to believe that H&Ms 100 designers created an identical slogan. Loks like a copycat job to me.
      • Kernal 2 months ago
        I like your picture :)
    • Waino  •  Kidderminster, England  •  3 months ago
      the grounds to tackle this on are stealing intellectual property since it it the idea behing the design that has been used for commercial gain
      • Ian 3 months ago
        How is this intellectual property, she didn't invent the phrase nor the use of a red love heart. Non of this is original work. Im sure ive used the phrase and probably written it down, does mean I own it.
      • izbit 3 months ago
        it could be classed as her intellectual property, but then the police can also say she has gratified the back of a road sign and prosecute her for that.
        Unfortunately she doesn't have a legal leg to stand on.
      • wrexked 3 months ago
        According to trademark law she would have to prove that the majority of the relevant public associate the phrase with her road sign rather than the H&M products to put a stop to them using it. H&M have a stronger case here.
    • Webster  •  Cardiff, Wales  •  3 months ago
      Thats ridiculous its obviously the same right down to the little love heart big companies stealing from little people again.
    • marya  •  Reading, England  •  3 months ago
      Designers do this all the time. I used to work for a company who sent people out to photograph found art and people with interesting handmade/personalised style. The stuff would come back and the 'trend setters' would take these ideas and work them into new designs. Now a lot of it's done through Google image search.

      Some guy saw that, probably on Google image search, and passed it along to the design team, who did their own version and started printing it on everything. The odds of the person who created the original design ever finding out used to be tiny, and even if they did there wasn't much they could do about it if the offence took place in another country due to the cost of international law suits. The internet and global communication has changed that: if there hadn't been a very public stink on Facebook, H&M would have just ignored her.
    • Brett  •  Madrid, Spain  •  3 months ago
      I am a graphic designer and in my considered opinion it is a direct copy
    • Waino  •  Kidderminster, England  •  3 months ago
      can't see any copyright sign on the original but yes that is blatant, does this mean another extradition
    • Robyn  •  London, England  •  3 months ago
      Is there even any question? Yes, yes they did steal it and yes i do think they should give Tori from Atlanta, Georgia the grace and payout she deserves for creating something so awesome that a top high street store had to steal it!
    • *  •  Hounslow, England  •  3 months ago
      blatant rip off and not grown up enough to admit it
    • roger m  •  Hounslow, England  •  3 months ago
      years ago my son entered a tv competition for drawing. He heard nothing from it. A couple of years later a cartoon started on tv with the character my son drew.
      Big business will steal, but because the small person has no copyright they have no leg to stand on.
    • Ron  •  Bromley, England  •  3 months ago
      why not a leg to stand on ? has she been on that roller coaster in Thorp Park ?
    • HWN147  •  Birmingham, England  •  3 months ago
      Looks like she has a good case against the to me. They may have 100 designers but it only take one copycat.
    • Karen  •  Loughborough, England  •  3 months ago
      So obviously a copycat! Shame on a big company like H&M not accreditting the design to this kind hearted lady!
    • Olly  •  Stockport, England  •  3 months ago
      I painted a sign once that said "Every little helps". Couldn't believe it when Tesco's ripped me off so I painted a new one, "Mums shop at Iceland"
    • TIM  •  London, England  •  3 months ago
      Who are H&M trying to kid? A blatant copy! Another case of a big corporation taking a big dump on the little guy.